Draconian laws and dereliction of duty – and it all took less than an hour


Standing on the road outside the controversial Pine Gap facility could be enough to land you in jail under the new law. Photo: Getty
Depending on what time you read this, Labor and the Coalition will have passed one of the most consequential and autocratic changes to Australia’s defence powers in half a century.
And they will have done it with the barest debate possible. And once passed, which looks like happening in a guillotine debate on Thursday afternoon, these laws are there until a future parliament overturns them.
Or, as is the bigger threat, makes them even more draconian.
A guillotined debate is what governments do when they want something passed quickly, and with as little notice and debate as possible.
It’s usually set when the numbers are already stitched up – the vote is a formality that has been worked out in backroom negotiations between ministerial offices and their non-government counterparts. It sets a time frame for when a bill has to be debated on, which means the President of the Senate has the power to stop the debate at the set time and force a vote.
It can limit debate to less than an hour. In less than an hour, Parliament can give politicians and public servants the power to override state, territory and Commonwealth laws while Defence can claim any part of Australia it wants as a security zone. That includes for things data centres, weapons tests and waste dumping.
Anywhere.
Australian citizens can be arrested and jailed for taking photos of anything within that zone, whether they know it is a security zone or not, in a slew of new offences that litter the bill that are combined with search and seize powers that would make a Trump ICE agent giddy.
Australian citizens can be detained by defence contractors, who will be authorised with search and seize powers – and have the authority to use dogs in detaining you, if they deem it necessary. But don’t worry, they have to stop short of killing you or causing you serious injury – unless the authorised officer “believes on reasonable grounds” the force was “necessary to protect life or to prevent serious injury”.
The bill is so broad, it includes the power to stop someone for doing “a thing”. “A thing” can be seized or searched. That “thing” can be searched or seized based just on a defence official (or a private contractor who has been given the authority) has a suspicion that the “thing” might be suspicious.
The legislation is so draconian, it includes the phrase “[a] person commits an offence if” 67 times. Decisions, once made, are reviewable only if you are a weapons or defence manufacturer who has been denied permission for something – not if you are a land or native title-holder, or concerned for the environmental impacts.
No one has to be consulted before a declaration is made and, even if consultation does occur, any concerns and objections count for nothing. There is no appealing decisions as a concerned citizen or land holder. The law sits above the courts. It amends 18 different acts. And it’s being passed (or, if you are reading this after midday on Thursday, likely has been passed) with the barest of scrutiny.
Even if you agree the laws are necessary – the government in its briefing to the few concerned senators who made the effort to understand this legislation said it was just to make existing laws clearer (not true) and give better drone defences – why the rush? This is the sort of legislation a government rushes through if it thinks it is going to war.
We have given the defence minister and all future defence ministers the power to make any area of Australia they want a defence “zone” without debate or examination. A moving vehicle can be a defence zone under this legislation. If you protest that truck – for example you see a Palintir-branded vehicle and stand in front of it, or attach a sign protesting Palintir, or pose any sort of “threat” to the truck and it has been declared a defence “zone” – that’s up to two years in prison. Whether you knew it was a zone or not.
For Australians who have protested Pine Gap, the threat is even higher. Pine Gap is mentioned as an example of a special defence security zone, which is the most serious of the designations. But that zone could include the access road in, which would circumvent pesky court rulings that have allowed protests to go ahead, finding in favour of civil liberties over defence secrecy. Standing along that access road, which is not inside the Pine Gap facility itself, could now land you in prison for seven years for “obstruction” of “the performance of an activity carried out for one or more defence purposes”. Even as a native title-holder. Those laws are easily overridden by this designation.
It doesn’t even have to be as obvious as Pine Gap. Any future defence minister could decide they believe creating a “regulated proximity area” is “reasonably necessary” and end protests.
Protesting a weapon’s manufacturer? Protesting a data centre? Protesting? The minister has said no. And that’s it. There is nowhere to appeal to.
At the same time, Australian defence ministers will have the power (at the recommendation of Defence, no doubt) over who to make “defence security officials”. Which is a very handy power to gift the US military as it exercises increasing power over Australian bases and sovereignty.
All at will. State, territory and Commonwealth laws overridden, with no appeals, at the will of the defence minister. With no checks and balances. No sunset clauses. All with barely a whisper from the mainstream media, or debate from politicians.
When people talk about the decline of democracy, this is what they mean. Not in big showdowns and obvious takeovers, but in bureaucratic and banal measures that are passed by democratic parliaments.
The dereliction of duty to Australians is not new. But it just got a hell of a lot more dangerous.
Amy Remeikis is a contributing editor for The New Daily and chief political analyst for The Australia Institute








