Why timing the market matters more than you think
A market downturn at the wrong time could leave retirees with lasting losses. Experts explain who is most at risk and how to protect your savings.

- The timing of market falls can have a lasting impact on retirement savings, particularly when investors need to withdraw money during a downturn.
- Australians approaching or entering retirement face the greatest risk, with less time to recover from investment losses.
- Holding cash for short-term expenses, diversifying investments and adjusting withdrawals can help reduce the need to sell assets at a loss.
Sequencing risk sounds complex.
Finance nerds use the term to describe a pitfall in saving and investing. But ordinary savers often find it difficult to understand something that only a financial planner finds interesting.
But ignoring it is a mistake. Once understood, sequencing risk can be key to a well-structured strategy that better withstands financial storms across your different life stages.
Sequencing risk refers to the timing of investment returns and the risk of needing to sell as financial markets fall.
“These two aspects operating together serve to amplify investment risk,” Dr Geoff Warren, Research Director at The Conexus Institute, told The Money Edition.
This occurred during the 2007-2009 Global Financial Crisis, peaking when global share markets suffered a series of daily 7-10 per cent drops in 2008.
Investors who did not need access to their investments were eventually vindicated when markets soared well above their pre-GFC levels.
Other investors who were on the point of retiring took a big hit if they needed to convert investments into income, thereby crystallising losses.
Over the course of their retirements, many have been unable to claw back what was lost.
For investors who were still working or didn’t need the income, the sequence of that particular market fall and rise was manageable. For others, the order of events could not have been worse.
While it’s an extreme example, sequencing risk is not solely tied to retirement. There are other reasons you may want to convert investments, and timing can substantially affect the outcome.

Who is most at risk?
Those in their 30s and 40s usually have a long enough time horizon to manage market volatility and keep rebuilding after major dips.
Robert Devlin, Head of Advice & Partner at Tribeca Financial, works with clients, often in their 40s and 50s, who might want to retire early or have other priorities like helping out family or giving back.
He said sequencing risk is generally less of a concern for those still accumulating, as they have more time to recover from a downturn. It becomes more important once they start drawing on their investments.
Timing also comes into play when assisting clients who wish to invest significant amounts.
“We often have people moving large amounts into super. When investing a significant lump sum, we may stage that investment over time rather than putting it all into the market on one day,” Devlin said.
“That’s not about trying to time the market, but about reducing the impact of an unlucky entry point and helping clients stay disciplined with the agreed strategy.”
What is the ‘retirement risk’ zone?
This refers to a 20-year period immediately before and after retirement.
Investors in their 50s are considered to be in the first half of the ‘retirement risk’ zone with less time to recover from downturns (although it is unlikely they are making withdrawals on savings before the official Preservation Age of 60).
Those entering retirement, probably in their 60s, face the highest risk, as their savings are most likely at their highest point when they stop contributing, and withdrawals begin.
Can you plan for or avoid sequencing risk?
You cannot completely avoid market ups and downs, global crises, policy changes, your own longevity or inflation spikes.
“Most of the time, you cannot take risk off the table without taking returns off the table,” Dr Warren said.
Because sequencing risk is an interaction between return fluctuations and money out, lowering the risk of fluctuations typically means lowering your expected return.
You can, however, avoid making matters worse. Rushing to cash is not always the best strategy and bakes in losses you might otherwise have avoided.

Is asset allocation the answer?
Many financial professionals suggest “bucketing” investments as a useful framework.
Bucketing is shorthand for organising savings and investments by when you expect to spend them, in three broad buckets.
- Bucket 1 – Short-term, liquid, designed to cover your current spending needs (next 12-24 months)
- Bucket 2 – Mid-term investing, earning returns on a conservative allocation (which could include bonds, shares, etc)
- Bucket 3 – Longer-term investments in diversified growth assets which may include property or infrastructure.
The bucket theory is that earnings from Bucket 3 will progressively replenish Bucket 2, which tops up your ‘spending money’ in Bucket 1, reducing the need for a ‘fire sale’ of long-term assets if the markets fall.
You can review and rebalance this strategy at regular intervals. And if markets are strong, you can choose to sell and replenish the shorter-term bucket with maximum upside.
Lifetime income streams or annuities are often suggested as a way to overcome sequencing risk.
However, Dr Warren said sequencing considerations still apply when you buy a fixed annuity as you lock in income based on interest rates at the time.
When interest rates are high
Devlin also said that for pre-retirees with mortgages, “the scales can tip in favour of putting spare funds into a mortgage offset account, as the interest saving can provide an attractive, effectively tax-free return compared with taking investment risk elsewhere.”
This strategy also shows that there are many other ways to buttress your financial situation if you’re heading to retirement and locked into making withdrawals when markets are falling.
Some options include managing withdrawals by rescheduling your retirement exit, reconsidering discretionary spending, or delaying large purchases.
The information provided on this website is general in nature only and does not constitute personal financial advice. The information has been prepared without taking into account your personal objectives, financial situation or needs. Before acting on any information on this website, you should consider the appropriateness of the information having regard to your objectives, financial situation and needs.
Topics: Investing, Retirement