Subscribe
Advertisement

The economy explained. In your inbox twice a week.

The Money Edition

Why savings can take a bigger hit when markets fall

Retirees can face bigger investment losses than Australians still building their super, even when their money is invested in similar options. The reason comes down to tax.

Kaye Fallick

Retiree super
Retirees can face bigger losses than Aussies still building their super when markets fall, even if they hold similar investments. Photo: Pexels
  • Pension accounts generally deliver higher returns than accumulation accounts when markets rise, thanks to tax-free investment earnings.
  • When markets fall, tax benefits can cushion losses in accumulation accounts, but pension accounts don’t receive the same benefit.
  • Super funds are being urged to explain these differences more clearly to members making retirement decisions.

Yes, superannuation is complex, but it shouldn’t be incomprehensible.

Advertisement

Last week a reader, Greg, asked The Money Edition why his pension fund showed such negative returns compared with an accumulation fund.

There’s a straightforward answer, but he felt his fund’s reply was initially wrong, then confusing.

The problem

“I cannot understand why it is that returns are worse in the pension phase of superannuation when returns are negative?” Greg wrote.

“I am with AustralianSuper and whenever returns are positive the pension account is approximately 1% higher than the equivalent investment option in an accumulation account.

“However, whenever returns are negative, the pension accounts are more negative than the accumulation accounts returns.

“When I phoned AustralianSuper about this, I had many interactions with ‘advisers’ that tried to explain that this wasn’t the case even though their website showed that it was.

“Finally, I was contacted by a senior adviser who agreed that this was the case and that it was a result of the taxation treatment of the returns.

“I was thankful for the acknowledgement, but I still did not understand how or why the tax would affect accumulation or pension superannuation accounts in different ways, depending upon whether they are positive or negative.

Subscribe here for our FREE Tuesday and Thursday newsletter

The response

The difference in returns comes down largely to how the two types of accounts are taxed.

In the accumulation phase, investment earnings are generally taxed at up to 15 per cent, while earnings in eligible retirement-phase pension accounts are tax-free.

This means pension accounts generally perform better when investment returns are positive, as members don’t pay tax on earnings or capital gains.

Advertisement

But the situation can reverse when markets fall.

“The opposite applies in periods of negative returns where super options can accrue deferred tax assets as underlying assets fall in value,” the adviser explained to Greg.

These tax benefits can help offset investment losses in accumulation accounts, while pension accounts do not receive the same benefit.

It’s not hard to see why Greg says he did not fully understand this explanation.

We contacted Joshua Lowen, Manager, Superannuation Research & Insights, at SuperRatings, who agreed this aspect of a fund’s performance can seem complicated.

He offered a plain English explanation of why accumulation and pension accounts can produce different returns, even when invested in similar options.

“The most likely reason accumulation and pension returns are different, even when the option looks the same, is because the government taxes these accounts differently,” Lowen said.

When Australians are building their super, tax on investment earnings reduces the returns they receive. But once they move into an eligible retirement-phase pension account, those earnings are generally tax-free.

superannuation tax
Tax rules can give retirement-phase pension accounts an advantage when markets rise, but the opposite can happen when investments lose value. Photo: AAP

This means retirees can receive higher returns when markets are rising. The difference becomes more confusing when markets fall.

In accumulation accounts, investment losses can reduce the fund’s tax liability, helping to cushion the impact of falling asset values.

Pension accounts, however, do not pay tax on investment earnings, so there is no equivalent tax benefit to soften the loss.

“But pension accounts don’t pay tax, so they can’t do this, and the full loss is applied to your account,” Lowen said.

Advertisement

He stressed that these tax rules apply across the superannuation industry, not just to AustralianSuper.

Lowen said members comparing returns should consider how long they intend to remain invested, ensure they are comparing options with similar levels of risk and return, and contact their fund or a financial adviser before changing their investment strategy.

Funds need to do better

Greg did, of course, contact his fund more than once.

He believes these fluctuations, amplified by tax treatment, need to be disclosed more clearly when members are considering their retirement options.

We also asked Xavier O’Halloran, CEO of advocacy group Super Consumers Australia (SCA), what members should reasonably expect.

“These are questions that super funds should be able to answer. It is disappointing that the super fund didn’t do a better job in this case,” he said.

“We know super funds have been asking the Government for concessions to make it easier for them to provide advice, including watering down consumer protections.

hack superannuation
Super funds are facing calls to provide clearer explanations of investment returns and help members better understand their retirement savings. Photo: AAP

“But this is one they can actually answer under the current law and without additional charges, through what is known as intrafund advice.”

Intrafund advice is provided by a super fund and can cover a member’s investment options or insurance.

“So a question, like this one, about how different investment options at the fund are taxed, and the impact on returns, should be their bread and butter,” O’Halloran said.

“Funds have been poor at servicing their customers’ needs; you can see this in spiralling complaints about poor customer service and the regulator taking AustralianSuper and CBUS to court in recent years over bad customer service.

“If funds want to genuinely help people planning for retirement, they need to get better at doing the basics, like picking up the phone and answering people’s questions.”

Last word

Super is complex, but funds have a responsibility to provide timely and comprehensible explanations of the rules and returns.

Greg’s issue was further complicated by the industry’s propensity to use different terms for what are essentially saving (accumulation) and spending (decumulation) accounts.

The critical difference between the two is, of course, tax treatment. It shouldn’t be that hard to say this, should it?

“Our contact centre helps members every day with a range of enquiries on complex financial matters, and we do our best to accurately explain them in simple terms where possible,” a spokesperson for AustralianSuper told The Money Edition.

“We also have a number of tools available to help members understand their financial position, including webinars, in-person seminars, and articles on our website.

“Members can also book in for more personalised advice with one of our 4500 registered advisers.”

Topics: AustralianSuper, Retirement, superannuation

Advertisement