Subscribe
Advertisement

The economy explained. In your inbox twice a week.

The Money Edition

‘Materially sharper downturn’: Why three RBA board members voted no to rate hike

Minutes from the last RBA monetary policy meeting reveal why three members voted against hiking the cash rate.

Stuart Marsh

interest rates
The exact arguments for - and against - raising the cash rate have been revealed. Photo: TND
  • Minutes from the last RBA monetary policy meeting reveal why three members voted against hiking the cash rate.
  • The three members, the identities of which we don’t know, felt that the economy was on the verge of a steeper downturn than expected.
  • These members, the minority, felt that the housing market and rising unemployment meant it was unnecessary to hike rates for a sixth time this year.

Three members of the Reserve Bank of Australia’s (RBA) monetary policy board voted against hiking interest rates because they felt the economy was on the verge of a “materially sharper downturn.”

Advertisement

Revelations from the RBA minutes, which detail what went on inside the room at the bank’s last meeting, show the vote to hike rates was split.

Six members believed there was a risk that higher inflation would become expected in the economy, and businesses would pass on more costs to consumers.

However, three members believed that there was no need to hike rates again so soon, and that “the prevailing downside risks made it prudent to wait for more evidence before deciding.”

Reserve Bank of Australia Governor Michele Bullock said the hike was a case of “some pain now to avoid pain later.” AAP Image/Dean Lewins

“A minority of members determined instead that the case to leave the cash rate target unchanged at this meeting was the stronger one,” the minutes reveal.

“These members expressed their concern that the economy might be near the point of entering a materially sharper downturn and pointed to the costs in terms of unemployment.”

Another concern was the housing market, which is currently suffering the steepest downturn in around 40 years.

“Another prominent risk related to the cyclical downturn in the housing market,” the minutes reveal.

“Members noted that it was possible that the decline in housing turnover would reduce economic activity by more than the average historical response incorporated in the central forecasts, as envisaged in the staff’s downside scenario.

Subscribe here for our FREE Tuesday and Thursday newsletter

“That, in turn, would worsen the outlook for the labour market and dampen wage and price inflation.

“Downside risks might be further amplified if sentiment towards data centre construction proved more fragile than anticipated, as suggested by financial market movements in the lead-up to the meeting.”

The RBA minutes do not specify the identities of the members who voted, only the result of the vote.

Advertisement
unemployment rate
Some members were concerned that unemployment was already rising faster than expected. Photo: AAP

A full list of everyone who sits on the RBA monetary policy board can be seen on its website.

Ultimately, given the majority opted to increase rates, the RBA delivered another 25 basis point hike on Melbourne Cup Day.

Australia’s cash rate target now sits at 4.85 per cent, having risen five times this year.

NAB economist Taylor Nugent said the minutes reveal that there is still some risk of yet another hike.

“The November majority’s concern about inflation expectations leaves some residual risk of a further increase amid uncertainty about both the extent of domestic capacity pressures and whether policy is sufficiently restrictive,” write Nugent.

“But we think this risk is only modest.”

Nugent said NAB maintains its case that the RBA has hit its peak with the current hiking cycle, and will now wait and watch how the 125 points flow through to the economy.

“NAB’s view remains that 4.85 per cent will mark the peak in policy rates,” Nugent said.

“We forecast a little more cooling in the labour market and a little softer GDP growth than the RBA, and expect that to open up space for incrementally less restrictive policy next year, expecting the first cut in August.”

Topics: Interest Rates, RBA

Advertisement