Advertisement

Alan Kohler: The rise of the far right, and the fall of Donald Trump

The next test of the far right will be led by Marine Le Pen and Giorgia Meloni, Alan Kohler writes.

The next test of the far right will be led by Marine Le Pen and Giorgia Meloni, Alan Kohler writes. Photos: Getty

It will be nowhere near as consequential, but the next battle in the war between the Right and the Left that started with the French Revolution won’t be the US presidential election in November, but next week’s election of 720 members of the European Parliament.

In many ways it will be a better reflection of which side is winning because the two leaders of the European far Right, Italy’s prime minister Giorgia Meloni and France’s Marine Le Pen, are far more appealing and electable than their American counterpart, Donald Trump, especially now that he’s a convicted felon.

And the signs are that the candidates backed by Meloni and Le Pen will do very well next week, and that the far Right will do better in this European election than it has ever done before, and possibly even gain a majority.

The European Parliament has long been dominated by a coalition of the centre left (the social democrats) and the centre right (the Christian democrats), and although its power as a transnational body is limited, it has always been a key institutional asset of the global Left.

With the rise of popular right-wing parties in Italy, France, Spain and the Netherlands, something similar is now expected to happen in Brussels.

Change tipped

If the centrist parties lose this election, or even come close to losing, it will be an earthquake for internationalism generally, including the International Court of Justice and the United Nations.

Actually, it’s probably better to replace the terms Right and Left with Nationalist and Globalist: Nationalism and globalism have become the defining distinction of global politics over the past two decades, with the rise of the internet, global warming, China and uncontrolled immigration.

2016 was a big year for the nationalists with the Brexit vote in the UK in June and the election of Donald Trump in November, but with the pandemic and the election of Joe Biden in 2020 and then Russia’s invasion of Ukraine in 2022, globalism reasserted itself.

In Australia the contest seems more complicated, although that may be simply because I’m close to it, so the trees are more evident than the forest.

Paul Kelly expressed that analysis in The Australian on the weekend: “The diversity of the chasm reveals its complexity – it includes identity politics, the climate threat, minority rights, rac­ism, environmentalism, educa­tional instruction, Australia’s history, migrant policy, religious freedom and Indigenous justice.”

Complexity on display

The complexity was on display in last week’s furore over ABC journalist Laura Tingle’s comment at the Sydney Writers’ Festival that Australia is a racist country.

Confusion and hypocrisy reigned. Free speech warriors decried her free speech and those who been denouncing the rise of antisemitism denounced her suggestion of widespread racism.

But the lesson of the Laura Tingle outrage, and on a larger scale that of Donald Trump, is that these days identity is everything, on both sides.

That is now evident in the response to Trump’s conviction on 34 counts of falsifying records in a Manhattan court, which is serving to deepen the divisions in the American polity, and society.

In Australia the mere suggestion of a criminal charge, or even that a married candidate slept with a porn star, would lead to immediate withdrawal and disgrace.

Money talks

But having been actually convicted by a jury of 12 ordinary citizens (not the prosecutor of the judge) Trump has not only vowed to press on and win, but he subsequently announced that his campaign had raised $US53 million ($80 million) in new donations since the verdict.

That was on top of $US50 million he raised at a donor event in Palm Beach Florida in April, taking him past Joe Biden in campaign funds for the first time.

American elections are as much a battle of money as popularity: A staggering $US16.4 billion was spent on the federal elections in 2020, including $US6.5 billion for the presidential election.

Trump is financially supported by millions of MAGA faithful making small donations as well as quite a few billionaires making big ones – the American plutocrats.

In his Chartbook newsletter over the weekend, Adam Tooze wrote: “This is not a matter of sophisticated economic ideology. They are not defending naive notions like “the free market”. They are defending an interest and they hurl their weight behind the Republican side, not as a matter of political whim, as Schwarzman or Paulson do, but because their lives depend on it.

“Stalwart in their defence of Trump in January 2021, what reason is there to believe that this social formation will defect over a “partisan judgment” in a “rigged” New York courtroom, over a small matter of hush money?”

Trump cannot win

But despite the rise of the far right, it seems to me Trump cannot win: He is now not only convicted felon, he has demographics against him.

Between the 2016 election and this year’s, about 18 million people over the age of 60 in the United States will have died and 30 million or so young Americans – Generation Z – will reach voting age. The issues that they care about – in particular climate change and reproductive rights – are mostly owned by the Democrats.

As Reed Galen, one of the founders of The Lincoln Project, an anti-Trump  Republican campaign outfit, wrote recently: “The Republican Party is on the wrong side of every major issue facing the American people.”

And it’s not as if Trump has a winning record. In 2016 when he won the electoral college, he lost the popular vote by 2.8 million votes, the largest margin of any US president in history. In the 2018 midterms, the Democrats easily beat the Republicans, in 2020 Trump narrowly lost the electoral college but lost the popular vote in a landslide, and in the 2022 midterms, Trump’s chosen candidates were routed across the country.

If Trump wins this year despite everything, America will be profoundly altered, in ways that are both frightening and impossible to predict.

Stakes raised

As New York Times writer David French, said in a podcast on the weekend: “If he wins anyway, the religious zeal around Donald Trump will be something to see. If we think that there has been a Trump cult already, if he wins in spite of all of this, the Trump cult will be – we will have seen nothing yet, is what I would say. And the level at which he would feel empowered to execute his objectives of vengeance – it would get truly scary, truly scary.”

So Friday’s verdict not only raises the temperature of the presidential campaign, it raises the stakes.

I had lunch with an American from North Virginia last week; a life-long Republican, he voted for Barack Obama in 2008 because he bought the optimism and promise of change, but became bitterly disillusioned when the change didn’t happen, or not enough of it, to his mind at least.

He believes the Democrats are fundamentally corrupt, running the country to line their own pockets. He doesn’t like Trump but says he couldn’t vote for Biden, so won’t vote at all – as in 2016 and 2020.

So the result on November 5 may be defined by those who don’t vote, or to put it another way, by whether Trump or Biden manages to persuade the largest number of his waverers to show up.

Alan Kohler writes weekly for The New Daily. He is finance presenter on the ABC News and also writes for Intelligent Investor

Topics: Donald Trump
Advertisement
Stay informed, daily
A FREE subscription to The New Daily arrives every morning and evening.
The New Daily is a trusted source of national news and information and is provided free for all Australians. Read our editorial charter.
Copyright Š 2026 The New Daily.
All rights reserved.