CBAās super funds still taking fees from the dead

Colonial First State, the superannuation arm of the Commonwealth Bank, is still taking fees from the super accountsĀ of dead people who signed contracts prior to the Future of Financial Advice reforms of 2013, the royal commission has heard.
Colonial First State general manager Linda ElkinsĀ said the bank was entitled to charge the fees on old accounts but was reviewing the practice.
āIt would be in the overall review that Iāve spoken about,ā she told the banking inquiry on Wednesday.
From 2016, the bank considered putting a rider in product disclosure statements telling investors that fees could be charged on the accounts of dead people. Ms Elkins said the internal view from 2018 was āwe probably should ceaseā ā and should never have charged the feesĀ at all.
CBA charged a 30 per cent fee on the revenue of its superannuation trustee following the introduction of a new super fund in 2018. The new fund was aimed at default MySuper customers, who tended to be disengaged and often have small balances.
Colonial executive Peter Chun defended the move, saying it was not designed to be a low-cost fund.
āIt was modelled on top-quartile funds,ā Mr Chun said, referring toĀ those that have feesĀ in the top quarter of those charged in similar funds.
The commission also heard that, in mid 2017, currentĀ CEO Matt Comyn tried toĀ persuadeĀ regulator ASIC to notĀ demand that CBA give an āenforceable undertakingā for misconduct. Mr Comyn instead offered forĀ the bankĀ to issue a media release detailing its breaches.
An enforceable undertaking (or EU) is a binding agreement made with ASIC that can be enforced in court.
An internal document described an action planĀ that involved Mr Comyn ringing ASIC deputy chair Peter Kell to talk him into accepting a media release rather than an EU. If that failed, the plan was to āwrite to ASIC ⦠accepting the EU in principal but seeking to discuss specific terms of the undertakingā.
Ms Elkins told the commission that CBA was not trying to change ASICās mind and wasĀ seeking details on what the regulator considered were āthe definitions of general advice versus personal adviceā.
ASIC refused CBAās arguments and put the EU in place. The breach involved CBA giving what regulatorsĀ consideredĀ āpersonal adviceā to customers in bank branches when selling superannuation products ā the bankĀ considered it general advice.
That distinction raised a response from Commissioner Kenneth Hayne, who expressed scepticism that selling super in a bank could be called āgeneral adviceā.
How could a super product be sold in branches āwithout those members of staff giving any personal advice?ā, Commissioner Hayne said.
It is far from apparent to me how that could possibly occur.ā
CBA also released details of the returns it paid on superannuation money invested in cash options following negative media coverage in June this year. At the time, CBA was charging administration fees on cash and market-based investments of 0.7 per cent and 0.36 per cent, with most options between 0.4 per cent and 0.48 per cent.
That stood starkly against the roughly 0.2 per centĀ benchmark set byĀ research house Chant West. At the time, CBA proposed new, lower, fees but these were still predominantly between 0.35 per cent and 0.5 per cent, with some options actually increasing.
Counsel assisting Michael Hodge put it to CBAāsĀ Ms Elkins that under-performance on cash returns was due to fees.
āFrom the perspective of Colonial the only explanation for the lower performance ⦠[was] that thereās a trailing commission.ā
āYes,ā Ms Elkins replied.
Detail on insurance costs found that, in most cases, Colonial super productsĀ had higher fees than the industryĀ average.
āWhen Comminsure [CBAās insurer] is above the median, it is well above the median. But when it is below the median, it is only a little below,ā Mr Hodge said.








