Jury begins to consider verdicts in camper murder trial

Greg Lynn (court sketch) is accused of murdering Carol Clay and Russell Hill in Victoria's high country.

Greg Lynn (court sketch) is accused of murdering Carol Clay and Russell Hill in Victoria's high country. Photo: TND

Twelve jurors have officially begun deliberating on whether former airline pilot Greg Lynn is guilty of the double murder of campers Russell Hill and Carol Clay.

The 57-year-old man faced a five-week trial where he denied killing the pair in Victoria’s alpine region in March 2020, but admitted removing their bodies and burning their remains.

He has been on trial in the Supreme Court in Melbourne since May 14 after pleading not guilty to two counts of murder.

Lynn claimed the two deaths were accidental.

The jury began deliberating on Monday, and it could take them hours, days or even weeks before reaching a verdict.

All jurors must unanimously agree on whether Lynn is guilty or not guilty of the two separate murder charges, before the verdicts can be delivered.

If one juror disagrees, they will not be able to reach a verdict and a fresh trial could be ordered.

The jury will consider only the two murder charges against Lynn as the alternative offences of manslaughter were thrown out.

Lynn told the jury Clay was shot in the head as he and Hill struggled over his shotgun. He claimed Hill then came at him with a knife and was fatally stabbed in the chest during a second struggle.

Lynn admitted he carried out “despicable” actions after the deaths, telling the jury he panicked and destroyed evidence because he feared his career would be over.

But prosecutor Daniel Porceddu told the jury Lynn’s story was a work of fiction and that he had “obliterated all evidence” to conceal the murders.

Justice Michael Croucher on Friday instructed the jury that Porceddu had breached the legal rule of fairness several times in his closing arguments.

The judge pointed to 16 instances where Porceddu made claims that had not been put to Lynn or a ballistics expert.

The directions were the final thing jurors heard before they were sent off to start deliberations.

Croucher reminded the jury there was no time limit to deliberations, although the verdicts needed to be unanimous.


Stay informed, daily
A FREE subscription to The New Daily arrives every morning and evening.
The New Daily is a trusted source of national news and information and is provided free for all Australians. Read our editorial charter.
Copyright © 2024 The New Daily.
All rights reserved.