Pauline Hanson’s tweet a ‘fairly strong form of racism’

Pauline Hanson's comments were a rhetorical device to criticise a Greens senator, her lawyer said.

Pauline Hanson's comments were a rhetorical device to criticise a Greens senator, her lawyer said. Photo: AAP

The federal One Nation leader’s response to a tweet about the death of Queen Elizabeth II was racist and likely to cause negative health impacts, a court has been told.

Senator Pauline Hanson is being sued for racial discrimination in the Federal Court by NSW Greens senator Mehreen Faruqi.

In September 2022, the Greens deputy leader tweeted that she could not mourn the death of Queen Elizabeth II as the leader of a “racist empire built on stolen lives, land and wealth of colonised peoples”.

Hanson responded, saying she was appalled and disgusted with Faruqi’s comments, telling her to “pack [her] bags and p–s off back to Pakistan”.

As the trial continued, Justice Angus Stewart heard evidence from two racism and discrimination experts about the potential impacts of the One Nation leader’s tweet.

Under cross-examination by Hanson’s barrister Sue Chrysanthou SC, Deakin University’s Professor Yin Paradies disagreed that there was no basis to say the tweet would affect readers.

“That form of racism … is likely to have a negative impact on somebody vicariously because it’s a fairly strong form of racism,” he told the court on Tuesday.

“It’s very exclusionary and it’s very much about who belongs and who doesn’t belong.”

While admitting that he did not have sufficient information on the views of all who read the tweet, including those who responded angrily to Faruqi, Paradies said this was not unusual when researching racism.

“The thing about racism is that we need to consider it as a pattern,” he said.

The court was told Paradies agreed with Faruqi’s views on colonialism, and had posted criticisms on Twitter on Australia Day in 2022 and 2023.

Last year, he posted that in 1788 “the most backward, ignorant, primitive, infantile, selfish, deluded, egoistic, sick and pernicious [mono]culture” had invaded and started annihilating one of the oldest and wisest societies on Earth.

“The vicious obliteration of this imponderably beautiful culture and the profound devastation of Country by patriarchal colonial capitalist (so-called) ‘civilisation’ continues unabated in 2023 as it has for the last 235 years,” he wrote.

Chrysanthou suggested these views had warped Paradies’ ability to objectively examine Hanson’s tweet.

“The fact of you holding those views … has affected your approach to answering the questions about my client’s conduct hasn’t it?” she said.

“I don’t think so,” Paradies said.

Professor Kate Reynolds of the Australian National University also gave evidence about what she described as the negative impacts of Hanson’s post.

“If someone experiences a tweet like this as racism, then it is likely that there will be a flow-on effect to poorer physical and mental outcomes,” she told the court.

As the trial opened on Monday, Chrysanthou said her client criticised Faruqi’s comments rather than targeting her because of race, colour of ethnicity.

The response was meant to show Faruqi was a hypocrite who insulted the late queen and the British Commonwealth but who still took advantage of all the benefits that living in Australia brought.

Hanson will take the stand later on Tuesday.


Stay informed, daily
A FREE subscription to The New Daily arrives every morning and evening.
The New Daily is a trusted source of national news and information and is provided free for all Australians. Read our editorial charter.
Copyright © 2024 The New Daily.
All rights reserved.